Connie Phillips Insurance

Submit a Claim

If this is an emergency, please call 911.

If you’ve been involved in an accident – or feel you need to file a claim – please feel free to call us. An agent will contact you shortly. For your convenience, the table below displays claims phone numbers and/or web links for many of our carriers.

AIC Agency Insurance Co (AIC) 1-800-841-5241, option 1
Allied Allied 1-800-532-1436, option 3
Brethren Mutual Brethren Mutual 1-800-621-4264, option 3
Chesapeake Employers Insurance Co Chesapeake Employers Insurance Co 1-800-264-4943
Donegal Donegal 1-800-877-9006
Encompass Encompass 1-800-588-7400
Foremost Foremost Foremost Claims Service
The Hartford Hartford 1-800-243-5860, option 1
(personal)
1-800-327-3636, option 1
(commercial)
Liberty Mutual Claims Center
Millers Mutual Millers Mutual 1-800-745-4555
MAIF MAIF 1-800-492-7114, option 3
NGM National Grange (NGM)
The Main Street America Group		 1-877-425-2467, option 3
Nationwide/Allied File an insurance claim
Penn National Penn National 1-800-388-4764, option 1, 2, 1
Philadelphia Insurance Companies Claim Center
Progressive Progressive 1-800-444-4487, option 1
Safeco Insurance Safeco Insurance Claims Center
Travelers Claim Center
Westminster American Insurance Company Claims