Submit a Claim

If this is an emergency, please call 911.

If you’ve been involved in an accident – or feel you need to file a claim – please feel free to call us. An agent will contact you shortly. For your convenience, the table below displays claims phone numbers for many of our carriers.

AIC Agency Insurance Co (AIC) 1-800-841-5241, option 1
Allied Allied 1-800-532-1436, option 3
Brethren Mutual Brethren Mutual 1-800-621-4264, option 3
Chesapeake Employers Insurance Co Chesapeake Employers Insurance Co 1-800-264-4943
Donegal Donegal 1-800-877-9006
Encompass Encompass 1-800-588-7400
Foremost Foremost File a claim online
The Hartford Hartford 1-800-243-5860, option 1
1-800-327-3636, option 1
Millers Mutual Millers Mutual 1-800-745-4555
MAIF MAIF 1-800-492-7114, option 3
NGM National Grange (NGM)
The Main Street America Group
1-877-425-2467, option 3
Penn National Penn National 1-800-388-4764, option 1, 2, 1
Progressive Progressive 1-800-444-4487, option 1